Mod Mmg,
To be honest I don't think it's so much the balance of the squeal - most people don't have an issue with how much XP or gold it gives. It's hardly overpowering. We all know this.
It's more the *principal* behind the wheel. I don't actually care if you give 1XP or 100K xp lamps, it's still selling experience, whilst indirectly, the avenue for it is there. I know you realize this as you have promoted the purchasing of experience in the past, such as Adventurer's Aplenty.
Secondly, the limited time promotions really do encourage purchasing of spins. That's the whole point of it, no? Otherwise you would not have designed it in such a manner. As such, the chances to obtain "x promotion item here" are not the same through free spins vs bought spins. Sure, you can obtain the yelp's amulet in 12 spins that you get from dailies, but you'd have to be extremely lucky, and hence buying spins gives you an advantage as such.
In all honesty I'd be less annoyed if I didn't have to see it every week. That way I can just ignore the feature I dislike about the game and get along with whatever it is I like to do on RuneScape. Feel free to promote it all you want on the Squeal of Fortune interface, but please dont' replace the awesome content the developers are putting out each week. I was saddened to see the GWD update pushed down because of a SoF update within 24 hours.
14-Sep-2012 21:17:44