Forums

§ RS Warring League §

Quick find code: 135-136-28-66059198

EbullientFew

EbullientFew

Posts: 4,236 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Also, on immunity/duration in between wars, I think the current period is fine. I think a week long break to chill (if wanted/needed by the clan) should certainly be an option. However, if a clan decides to invoke immunity, they should be prevented from issuing other challenges.

Additionally, most clans participate in more than one ladder and have been known to schedule more than one war at once. The one week immunity period and three week scheduling period give plenty of time and thus avoid scheduling conflicts- scheduling multiple wars between multiple clans can easily lead to conflicts.
Cheap and painless boss kills for comp, best service and prices. Click for more info- We sell all bosses!

19-Apr-2016 01:01:28

Kim Jan Zhao

Kim Jan Zhao

Posts: 124 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Original message details are unavailable.


This would be extremely difficult to organize and keep running, it also completely defeats the point of a "ladder" and detracts from the competitive nature of a ladder as such.


It does indeed defeat the point of a ladder because it is no ladder. I don't think it ruins the competitive nature of the fighting however because in this system every fight is worth points and thus worth it in the long run to end up first. They are very different systems, both have positives and both have negatives i wouldn't say one is more competitive than the other tho.

And yes this system would require more planning from the council, or other members helping the council; but considering the counsil is supposed to lead the leagues i don't see this as a problem because the seasons would practically be the same except maybe adding/withdrawing a few matches due to teams joining/leaving.

19-Apr-2016 01:05:35

Le Immortals

Le Immortals

Posts: 3,852 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
[quote id=388-389-147-65687771-761-338479122][quote id=388-389-147-65687771-757-338479044]but considering the counsil is supposed to lead the leagues i don't see this as a problem [/quote]Ah the council knew it would come up sooner or later, perhaps i'll write about that 2morro.
PvM Addicts
|
Le Immortals
|
CPK

19-Apr-2016 01:07:36

Try Hard
Oct Member 2020

Try Hard

Posts: 2,275 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
-If a team loses a rank they cannot redeclare on the same rank for a further 7 days, this is to stop ranks 1 and rank 2 always warring each other not allowing anyone else to war

yes I'm sitting here **** in hand in warbands ladder watching same 2 teams fight over and over
36/38 Boss Pets
Ex-Leader of
Divine Resilience

19-Apr-2016 01:09:48

Try Hard
Oct Member 2020

Try Hard

Posts: 2,275 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Immunity needs to be reduced, if you want to 'chill,' maybe because you're worn out- then decline the war. Simple as that, you can always challenge for it later. Support on 2 weeks to complete a war. If they're that busy that they can't find an hour over a 2 week period, then they probably can't find the time over a 3 week period either. Possibly if a universal major holiday occurs, could be extended to 3. Holidays would have to be clearly defined in advance. Also agree with 3 days to get back, 3 days to negotiate- it doesn't take more than that to survey 10 people, elongating that is just stalling. A warring league isn't too difficult to run, but you need teams that are motivated to participate. Good luck finding that. 36/38 Boss Pets
Ex-Leader of
Divine Resilience

19-Apr-2016 01:14:27

Prod
Mar Member 2013

Prod

Posts: 2,422 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Original message details are unavailable.
-If a team loses a rank they cannot redeclare on the same rank for a further 7 days, this is to stop ranks 1 and rank 2 always warring each other not allowing anyone else to war

Being high ranked on the ladder does suck at times because you can't choose who you fight until multiple teams challenge you on the same day, or under immunity. Calm already said Immunity would be reduced so there's literally no point in bringing it up furthermore. The Immunity and the Scheduling Wars part will be changed soon but changing the "multiclanning" would be difficult; only possible fixes would be giving a members list for both or just warring a select of people. Too much spam on this thread otherwise anyone else would read the rest....

19-Apr-2016 01:28:28

Sparing

Sparing

Posts: 51 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Not to step on anyones toes but personally this entire "immunity" after a war shouldn't really be there.... as to my knowledge pretty much everyone takes the weekdays off anyway due to school, work, etc.. this therefore means that no one will be warring during the weekdays anyway so each team will have aprox a week worth of just time to themselves before their next war. Just because you want to keep your rank 1 and claim "immunity" shows that you already know you may lose that so being rank 1.. you should want to defend your title instead of just avoiding a challenge.

Just an my own thoughts but I do think that the warring ladder should be a weekly event on the weekend, where each team will war other teams instead of challenging for rank 1 or 2 or w/e you are going for why not just have a point system where everyone has no choice but to face each other each weekend, this will therefore get everyone to war against every team so there will be no arguments for who declares on who and wins wins and losses will be put onto a score bored. This is just my idea as I personally find that there is a lot of drama for who is warring who and claiming immunity just because of w/e reason they come up with.

19-Apr-2016 01:29:56

Sparing

Sparing

Posts: 51 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Not to step on anyones toes but personally this entire "immunity" after a war shouldn't really be there.... as to my knowledge pretty much everyone takes the weekdays off anyway due to school, work, etc.. this therefore means that no one will be warring during the weekdays anyway so each team will have aprox a week worth of just time to themselves before their next war. Just because you want to keep your rank 1 and claim "immunity" shows that you already know you may lose that so being rank 1.. you should want to defend your title instead of just avoiding a challenge.

Just an my own thoughts but I do think that the warring ladder should be a weekly event on the weekend, where each team will war other teams instead of challenging for rank 1 or 2 or w/e you are going for why not just have a point system where everyone has no choice but to face each other each weekend, this will therefore get everyone to war against every team so there will be no arguments for who declares on who and wins wins and losses will be put onto a score bored. This is just my idea as I personally find that there is a lot of drama for who is warring who and claiming immunity just because of w/e reason they come up with.

19-Apr-2016 01:29:57

Prod
Mar Member 2013

Prod

Posts: 2,422 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Original message details are unavailable.
Not to step on anyones toes but personally this entire "immunity" after a war shouldn't really be there.... as to my knowledge pretty much everyone takes the weekdays off anyway due to school, work, etc.. this therefore means that no one will be warring during the weekdays anyway so each team will have aprox a week worth of just time to themselves before their next war. Just because you want to keep your rank 1 and claim "immunity" shows that you already know you may lose that so being rank 1.. you should want to defend your title instead of just avoiding a challenge.

Just an my own thoughts but I do think that the warring ladder should be a weekly event on the weekend, where each team will war other teams instead of challenging for rank 1 or 2 or w/e you are going for why not just have a point system where everyone has no choice but to face each other each weekend, this will therefore get everyone to war against every team so there will be no arguments for who declares on who and wins wins and losses will be put onto a score bored. This is just my idea as I personally find that there is a lot of drama for who is warring who and claiming immunity just because of w/e reason they come up with.

You posted this 3 times, and immunity is there to give the defending team time to work out times and possible dates, since if you don't answer/reply after 3 days, you'll automatically forfeit unless you give them the contact or counter proposal. If you can't come to an agreement on scheduling a team; a date and time will be picked for you a week later, thanks. Read the front pages before you post :P

19-Apr-2016 01:35:48

Quick find code: 135-136-28-66059198 Back to Top