Forums
Clan Cup - Suggestions thread
Quick find code: 86-87-185-65809849
Should be all for now off the top of my head..
Going to edit the post a bit to actually make them legible
-
Clam Enigma's evil twin | Council of the RS
-•¤{
Going to edit the post a bit to actually make them legible
-
C.E.
Clam Enigma's evil twin | Council of the RS
W
arring League
-•¤{
Wicked
Fury
}¤•-
05-Jul-2016 21:11:00
Also to answer a few points brought here...
RCW v Gamer's Grotto
Honestly, whether you prefer the RCW map or the gamer's grotto map is a matter of taste. For non-JCup wars, F2P have historically used centrebounds in the classic map and P2P have historically used turrets. However, that is a preference and the RCW map isn't really gamebreaking in at all. It's just different from what warrers are used to, but to any other player (and a lot of warrers themselves) the map is really just a minor issue gameplay-wise. The more annoying thing is that you can't spectate RCW wars.
With namechanges, it's unreasonable for us to try and keep track of every clan's memberlist so it is necessary that only official clanmates participate in the Cup. So for those hosting the Cup, RCW has the advantage of making sure all participants are in the same clan, which can save a lot of trouble over disputes about fielding outsiders. On the other hand, if we use the dispute procedure where the accusing clan has to present evidence to back up its accusation, it could be possible to use turrets as we wouldn't have to go dig up evidence ourselves.
1v1 PvM Cup and Duel-anywhere Cup
1v1 PvM would probably require much more monitoring than the organisers can feasibly manage - notably keep track of drops and having to be present to ensure no rules are being broken.
Duel anywhere is too loose a mechanic as anyone can run into the area and duel if they wish - I don't see any way in which it could be incorporated into a Clan Cup. Furthemore, I think the organisers will have their hands full with just the standard 3 Cups
-
Clam Enigma's evil twin | Council of the RS
-•¤{
RCW v Gamer's Grotto
Honestly, whether you prefer the RCW map or the gamer's grotto map is a matter of taste. For non-JCup wars, F2P have historically used centrebounds in the classic map and P2P have historically used turrets. However, that is a preference and the RCW map isn't really gamebreaking in at all. It's just different from what warrers are used to, but to any other player (and a lot of warrers themselves) the map is really just a minor issue gameplay-wise. The more annoying thing is that you can't spectate RCW wars.
With namechanges, it's unreasonable for us to try and keep track of every clan's memberlist so it is necessary that only official clanmates participate in the Cup. So for those hosting the Cup, RCW has the advantage of making sure all participants are in the same clan, which can save a lot of trouble over disputes about fielding outsiders. On the other hand, if we use the dispute procedure where the accusing clan has to present evidence to back up its accusation, it could be possible to use turrets as we wouldn't have to go dig up evidence ourselves.
1v1 PvM Cup and Duel-anywhere Cup
1v1 PvM would probably require much more monitoring than the organisers can feasibly manage - notably keep track of drops and having to be present to ensure no rules are being broken.
Duel anywhere is too loose a mechanic as anyone can run into the area and duel if they wish - I don't see any way in which it could be incorporated into a Clan Cup. Furthemore, I think the organisers will have their hands full with just the standard 3 Cups
-
C.E.
Clam Enigma's evil twin | Council of the RS
W
arring League
-•¤{
Wicked
Fury
}¤•-
05-Jul-2016 21:44:50
Quick find code: 86-87-185-65809849 Back to Top