Forums

Trolls

Quick find code: 74-75-546-66276611

Seasons Past

Seasons Past

Posts: 559 Steel Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Hi everyone,

After writing about the Burthorpe tutorial, one thing that stuck out to me was how trolls are generally portrayed in the game. The premise of the Burthorpe tutorial revolves around preparing a counterattack against the trolls. This seems reasonable, as the town has in fact been repeatedly attacked by invading trolls from the north.

Then I thought about the means and motivations of each side. The Burthorpe Imperial Guard are defending their settlement against invaders - fair enough. That leaves the question of why the trolls are attacking.



I said, why are the trolls attacking?

Ah yes, this is the problem.

On side A we have:
Valiant warriors heroically defending their culture against evil outsiders.

On side B we have:
Brutes who lack advanced technology, infrastructure, and grasp of language - who also happen to be an entirely different species and therefore not human.

I’m not going to expand on why I think the Burthorpe tutorial should be removed even if another tutorial doesn’t replace it, as I already explained that in another thread. The point is that this is a problem.
Spirit of Forinthry ~ Runecrafting: Magic Armour ~ F2P Extensions ~ Dragon Slayer improvements ~ New Player Experience

15-Mar-2023 21:01:11

Seasons Past

Seasons Past

Posts: 559 Steel Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Here are some suggestions and other notes to consider:

1. Move further away from the idea that all trolls are unintelligent.
-A few trolls, such as the ice troll child and his parents encountered during Desert Treasure, are depicted as culturally similar to humans. This narrative thread could be developed further.
-It’s likely that there are cultural differences among trolls. For example, perhaps ice trolls are for some reason more cooperative and interested in non-troll cultures. This would be comparable to the difference between Zamorakian and Zarosian Mahjarrat, for example.
-Perhaps the ice trolls broke away from mountain trolls at some point, wanting to live in seclusion from the latter’s more primitive ways. Many ice trolls remain hostile to intruders, as they do not wish to be disturbed.

2. Make the perspective more balanced. Instead of showing them as dumber, uglier humans, reframe trolls as having a distinct culture, by building on what is known or can be inferred about them:
-Trolls are warlike and generally hostile to outsiders.
-Trolls inhabit harsh climates, leading their societies to value traits such as physical strength and endurance.
-Trolls traditionally have not practiced agriculture, as it was infeasible in their homeland. Thus, they are largely scavengers. Fortunately, they are also omnivores, which helps them survive.
-Trolls do not have a written language, as it simply was not a priority given the constant pressures on their survival. As such, knowledge is passed through oral tradition.
-It is known that trolls are capable of practicing magic. It is likely that they have some sort of spiritual culture (as they have shamans), which could be elaborated.
Spirit of Forinthry ~ Runecrafting: Magic Armour ~ F2P Extensions ~ Dragon Slayer improvements ~ New Player Experience

15-Mar-2023 21:01:59 - Last edited on 15-Mar-2023 21:18:05 by Seasons Past

Seasons Past

Seasons Past

Posts: 559 Steel Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Continued below:

3. Existing quests have skilfully managed to explore complex and sensitive issues in a balanced manner.
-In Troll Romance, a limerent youth, Ug, pines over his crush, Aga. The story is not merely about unrequited love. Ug is clearly out of place among his tribe, which exhorts strength, stature, and brute force as standards for success in troll society, leaving no room for sensitive personalities (although it is not known whether these expectations apply equally to females). As per my interpretation in the first point, Ug seems to be more of an ice troll - at least in spirit - than a true mountain troll.
-In My Arm’s Big Adventure, a curious and adventurous young troll wants to discover the secrets of agriculture after being inspired by contact with the outside world.
-The themes explored in both of these quests are as timeless as they are endearing. How societies and individuals adapt to changing conditions and confront differences in values is a question that never gets old.
-Many other RuneScape quests and lore carry the theme of how cultural exchange and questioning of values are a double-edged sword, leading to great benefit but also to conflict. Besides the Troll series, the Goblin and Fremennik quest series are strong examples. The Legends’ Quest also provides a good example of how to explore these sorts of delicate topics.

I’m leaving this open-ended, as I think it warrants further discussion.
Spirit of Forinthry ~ Runecrafting: Magic Armour ~ F2P Extensions ~ Dragon Slayer improvements ~ New Player Experience

15-Mar-2023 21:02:49 - Last edited on 15-Mar-2023 21:19:42 by Seasons Past

Quick find code: 74-75-546-66276611 Back to Top