Cozmic,
Three things here:
1) I was a judge for Innue's *Official* Story Contest. This was the official competition not judged by Jagex Staff.
2) I think that weight should be put on the number of competitors in the contest when adjudicating who places where and when. There is a difference between placing first out of eight and placing first out of eighty, and we should account for that difference in some way.
Furthermore, we should count finalist places for the Trontests, because he did not announce the top three. In this way, Bunni Killer, a prolific competitor and wonderful author, progressed to three finals whereas someone else who may be listed fourth (for sake of neutrality) may have only progressed to one final or none at all. I have lists for several of the Trontests if that information is necessary. I simply think it unfair to penalise the finalists of the early competitions and bestow, therefore, unqualified titles on others simply because they began to compete under the newer model.
3) Can you list the total point value for each ranking user on the first page? I think that would be useful in utilizing the rankings for self improvement and juxtaposition rather than mere superlatives.
I look forward to continued improvements in the Hall of Fame.
--Yrolg
PS-- I won the FunOrb competition administered by Mod Craddock. I would appreciate that being accounted for in the rankings.
11-Jul-2012 17:18:30
- Last edited on
11-Jul-2012 17:22:56
by
Yrolg
