Forums

-=± Outlander ±=-

Quick find code: 49-50-803-41843837

Deanfoley1

Deanfoley1

Posts: 6,326 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Just finished reading all the first page, I'm still rrading currently, but here's a few comments just for this moment:
Compliments:
------------
The scene is very well set, in a swirl of advanced vocabulary, which opens up a good deal of description. Charachter development was astouding, his actions clearly showed he was a social boy, who hated to feel left out, and hated feeling incompetent. He was also somewhat of a pacifist, he did not like to fight back to his comrades, he usually remsined passive.
As far as criticism goes, I did devolep a few as I read, as I do with every story, but they were quickly hammered away.

24-Apr-2007 11:17:11

Deanfoley1

Deanfoley1

Posts: 6,326 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
By hammered away, I meant it was quickly shown to be untrue.

But if you truly want criticism, I will unleash my cold reviewing heart } :) .

Description is always a vital part in any story, yet it can break a story if used at the wrong times. In my personal opinion, using it dead at the beggining is not a good manoeuvre. It can somewhat bore a reader, and the typical skimmer will be detered. I believe it's best to start with a bit of action, loose a hook, grab the reader and then let them sink into the true diolouge.

Being that Action stories, partiularly wars for a quaternery point of view, this has always been easy for me, but it's possible for most stories. You could've began with a hunt, for example. Lets just face it, a lot more readers would be hooked by flying axes at the beggining.

All a matter of opinion, of course ;) .

Edit: Aww, stupid smilie things automaticly blocked my 'Evil smilie' :( .

24-Apr-2007 17:23:14 - Last edited on 24-Apr-2007 17:24:22 by Deanfoley1

Roshinda

Roshinda

Posts: 6,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Still two posts from 400 :(
Well, one post now. Who will get it I wonder?
Dean, you do make a good point, a lot of people get hooked by action. If there is a prolouge, usually it is an action scene. I've had lots of positive comments about how gripping the first paragraph of my story is though, just because of how descriptive it is. As I said, not everything appeals to all readers.
Thanks for your comments though :)

24-Apr-2007 22:25:55

Quick find code: 49-50-803-41843837 Back to Top