The Other Storyteller
This piece has real potential. I really, really liked what I read; it was original and yet enchanting. I love the explanation Demetri provides for what would happen if she were to die later on. It's pure and total manipulation, but I think you pulled this tricky task off. I'd be careful about the discussions, however: they sometimes border on the unbelievable.
I'd focus on proofreading the piece, though. It's terribly ridden with errors, some of them elementary and some of them just plain stupid mistakes. I'd also try to make the ending a little less cliché: happy endings are fine, but they are all the same. Try to put some realistic twist on the ending so that it's upbeat but not "happily ever after", fairy-tale quality.
The Poisoned Goblet
This piece was more dark, but I think it was more my style than the previous. I like the idea of internal struggle; it's something that isn't very common on these forums but it's integral for every major novel of depth.
I found that the diction was, at times, unbecoming and that you seemed to try to hard in describing the things. Also, instead of shimmering green liquid, I think it would have been appropriate (and cool) if he had seen his reflection in a dark liquid (perhaps a red wine or dirty water). He could have contemplated his past life then, and it wouldn't have seemed so narrative.
I'd watch out for repeating names too often. In both pieces you shied from using pronouns, when, in fact, pronouns are commissionable tools for increasing flow.
I don't quite understand how a seemingly fluorescent green liquid was water. This made the plot iffy.
I liked the witty ending.
31-Dec-2010 23:39:46
- Last edited on
31-Dec-2010 23:48:06
by
Yrolg