forums.rs

Forums

Dungeoneering

Quick find code: 317-318-258-66282178

of 3
Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,201 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
We do not have "dung" in this game, and that's why OP discussed about adding it. If you reason for not having "dung" in OSRS is we didn't have it in 2012 then I believe most players' response would be "ROFL" as we have a lot of things in OSRS now that we didn't have in 2012.

We didn't have "dung" in 2012 that reward clan people whatsoever. Please get your fact straight first. Any random players can form a group in "dung" just like what we have now in 2023 raids.

"The only way would effectively be to create a clan of your own just to do the
skill
."


Skill? I clearly wrote on Page 1, Post 7, I would not like "dung" to be a skill in 2023 OSRS. Some "Dung" content would be good to have. You are just barking up the wrong tree. You better worry about Sailing rather, as it is a skill and will reward players selling carries.

25-Jun-2023 00:06:59

mastercast3r
Mar Member 2023

mastercast3r

Posts: 438 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dilbert2001 said :
If you reason for not having "dung" in OSRS is we didn't have it in 2012. My reasoning for it is that it would not fit the game as is. It would never be voted in PERIOD, because they would never poll it.

As I said, IF they were to give a tiny group huge bonuses, it would not pass. IF the only way to get those bonuses would be to totally change the way you play the game, the vast majority would not be interested in voting for it.

IF they were to some how added without those bonuses those that think they deserve those bonus would be enough to sink any chance of it passing.

Jagex does not poll lost causes. DUNG is a lost cause.

IF you do not want it to be a skill, why are you arguing.

When the skill was added to rs2, they never asked the players what they wanted. OSRS does ask, and we have stated categorically, we do not want this as a skill. So why are you arguing that we should consider polling it as a skill. THAT is what the op wants, the
SKILL
called dung.

25-Jun-2023 00:15:47 - Last edited on 25-Jun-2023 00:19:29 by mastercast3r

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,201 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
"Jagex does not poll lost causes. DUNG is a lost cause."


Jagex OSRS does not poll whenever they don't want to poll, even when they expected the poll will pass (e.g. Runious Power). Polling is a joke in OSRS. Fixed it for you.

I don't see anywhere anybody proposed "huge bonus" or "clan" anyway. The DG content I suggested are sinkholes and such. They don't involve any clan whatsoever and there is never "bonus" playing with anybody there.

Who is arguing? I am putting up my comments for discussion. I don't see OP asked for a Dungeoneering
skill
anyway. Looking through all the comments from all the players, you are the only one trying to argue about "skill".

25-Jun-2023 00:22:50 - Last edited on 25-Jun-2023 00:27:16 by Dilbert2001

mastercast3r
Mar Member 2023

mastercast3r

Posts: 438 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dilbert2001 said :
Who is arguing? I am putting up my comments for discussion. I don't see OP asked for a Dungeoneering
skill
anyway. Looking through all the comments from all the players, you are the only one trying to argue about "skill".

In rs3, it is a skill.
Moses_six7 said :
I know it’s not a OSRS 2007 thing but would it be possible to bring dungeoneering to OSRS it was so fun to do The op wants to bring dung as it is. THAT is a skill. Granted I have not been in rs3 since 2013, but the last time I heard was it was one of many skills in the game. Have they removed it as a skill and turned it into a minigame now?

Edit: I just read the wiki and there is nothing about anything except it being a skill where people basically do raid, but get skill and everything seems to be precisely the same as it was in 2013.

IF you have a suggestion for bring part of it to this game, suggest those parts.

25-Jun-2023 00:44:27 - Last edited on 25-Jun-2023 01:01:26 by mastercast3r

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,201 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
^^
Whatever names in RS3 don't have to be referring to the same things in OSRS and vice versa.

In RS3, Necromancy is a full scale and the biggest ever skill. It is also the 4th ever Combat Style in Jagex's history. In OSRS, Necromancy is just a small piece of magic content. The differences are incredibly obvious.

OP didn't mention anything about 2013 dungeoneering skill. If you want to argue with him, be my guest. It doesn't bother me. The main point of my comments to you specifically is to correct what you think about clans and buffs in any form of dungeoneering in any year. They simply don't exist, and never existed. That's why randoms players are buying/selling leeches similar to what they do with raid carries now.

25-Jun-2023 01:00:00 - Last edited on 25-Jun-2023 01:04:27 by Dilbert2001

jawn snow3
Aug Member 2019

jawn snow3

Posts: 73 Iron Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Recently starting playing DG on my old RS3 account (new main is OSRS) with a buddy and it's still so fun.. Couldn't agree more with them re-implementing dung into OSRS. Rewards were amazing and the skill concept itself was extremely well rounded. I know I may be alone on this next one, but wish they'd add summoning back as well. Used to be a big time player before EOC and finally achieved overloads, chaotics, turmoil and pack yack before they changed it all...was the pinnacle of RS back then in my opinion. If only...

26-Jun-2023 06:31:59

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,201 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
jawn snow3 said :
Recently starting playing DG on my old RS3 account (new main is OSRS) with a buddy and it's still so fun.. Couldn't agree more with them re-implementing dung into OSRS.
Rewards were amazing and the skill concept itself was extremely well rounded.
I know I may be alone on this next one, but wish they'd add summoning back as well. Used to be a big time player before EOC and finally achieved overloads, chaotics, turmoil and pack yack before they changed it all...was the pinnacle of RS back then in my opinion. If only...

The great things in RS3 like amazing rewards and well rounded skill concept is exactly why DG won't happen in OSRS. Great rewards in RS3 like Chaotic gear will be power creep in OSRS without a doubt. We see how Ruinous Powers fared. The "extremely well rounded skill concept" in RS3 will never apply to OSRS as skillers are trash in OSRS. There are just aimlessly grinding levels and never a part of the in game economy.

26-Jun-2023 17:08:19 - Last edited on 26-Jun-2023 17:08:57 by Dilbert2001

mastercast3r
Mar Member 2023

mastercast3r

Posts: 438 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Dilbert2001 said :
skillers are trash in OSRS. There are just aimlessly grinding levels and never a part of the in game economy. When the game came out we WERE the economy. It was not until Jagex decided to get rid of them that they changed the game from a skilling economy to a pvmers/bosser economy. The reason bonds are not at 8 mil is that jagex decided to dump tons of resources that should have come from skillers on mob drops.

When bonds were 1 mil, you could get a mil from skilling in a few hours. Now that they are 8 mil and the resources have drop so bad, it take DAYS to get a bond and then only if you have high level skills.

This is why we never see 500k players online and its not uncommon to see less than 50k. When skillers were the economy, we never saw less than 250k. Now they brag if they see 125k.

30-Jun-2023 01:34:33 - Last edited on 30-Jun-2023 01:36:04 by mastercast3r

Quick find code: 317-318-258-66282178 Back to Top