This would be a piece of nostalgia at best, rather like RS Classic. I joined in 2008 ish (though have played continuously since) so for me this would be an RS I never even knew first time around. A game with a lot fewer items has its appeals but a PK wildy (pre- removal) is as bad as the reinstated one (my view), no ge would mean a return to shouting in banks to trade, removal of present skills (and quests) added since, wind back of stats and no updates plus perhaps an extra fee to play it - none of this sounds very appealing. Folks clamouring for the old days are trying to re-capture their feelings of the time in my view rather than really want an old game.
I do love old games and value their simplicity. Indeed, I love it when I find things like Chip's challenge, some of the Mac galactic empire type games and so on in online presently playable versions, but RS is one I play too seriously in the 'now' version to want to look this far back on it. There are lots of things I dislike about the 'new game' but I don't feel the old version will 'mend that' because it throws out the good with (my view) bad. Also to a modern audience, especially a target audience of teens the old game would be laughable. Now of course I am NOT a teen (lol many times) and do believe the older players that presently play RS are not sufficiently appreciated, catered for or considered in designing (most) content and maybe this idea is a nod in our direction, but not in my view the right one. Instead please give us more polls about what we might want and keep going on things like Runefest (but maybe an online version that most of us could actually afford to attend!) where hard core fans can tell you what they are looking for.
My support would be lukewarm I have to say for bringing back the 2007 game.
14-Feb-2013 01:59:18