What I find interesting in that thread is the fact that all of page 1 and most of page 2 is in fact harping down the original poster. Flaming them. Their reasoning may not be the best calling people that enjoy chopping wood for 10+hours a day bot like. However they didn't flat out call the community botters.
I'd also point out they may have gotten used to the food hp scaling in RS3 as we do have that. However it was designed to make use of lower tiers of food giving them a usefulness as everyone in the wilderness would use sharks and above to instant heal to full health. So using food below a certain hp tier doesn't yield the best results as there are foods more suited for your health level available.
Granted do I think it will pass a poll in the old school community certainly not. It wasn't til around EOC combat that the food to hp scaling existed. So I don't think a majority will be for it. However that isn't any reason to hurl insults at the poster and then say oh their flaming us... There is enough fire in that thread to have a wienie roast.
When the day becomes the night and the sky becomes the sea, when the clock strikes heavy and there’s no time for tea; and in our darkest hour, before my final rhyme, she will come back home to Wonderland and turn back the hands of time.