Forums
Off Topic Chat Lounge
Quick find code: 23-24-312-63626936
What about art, a genuine human expression? Artists
also
have a job: doing art. And it is a very important job, as necessary as other jobs in many fields of knowledge an it's also a serious activity that demands discipline and tenacity.
Why do art should be considered a job? Simple: just as medics work to change a given scenery of reality in an objective way (recovering health), the artists do the same... but in a subjective way: working to make us see reality from a different perspective. Both the medic and the artist should be able to live thanks to their own job, in other words, receive a decent payment that reflect their efforts.
I believe not. It lacks sensibility. And it lacks the important human capacity (yeah, it actually is) of making mistakes . Maybe the robot will perform the greatest of violin concerts without a single mistake, but if an artistic performance is defined as "a unique moment that it'll never repeat again" (even if the performers, musical piece and conditions are the same), then how a robot, which can't make mistakes (humans make mistakes, not machines) can make art? IT CAN'T.
Side note: academic musicians usually never read and play a given music sheet like a scanner would do at 100%, a fact which is remarkable with highly technical demanding works for piano concertos, such as the works of Liszt, Brahms or Rachmaninov. They usually play 80%-90% of all the notes... and do a lot of mistakes along the way.
What make us organic, human... living beings ? Making mistakes and learning from them. Something a machine will never do, if you remove the human factor.
Sorry for two long posts, it was something my soul felt the need to type down
Why do art should be considered a job? Simple: just as medics work to change a given scenery of reality in an objective way (recovering health), the artists do the same... but in a subjective way: working to make us see reality from a different perspective. Both the medic and the artist should be able to live thanks to their own job, in other words, receive a decent payment that reflect their efforts.
A robot playing violin can be called an artist?
I believe not. It lacks sensibility. And it lacks the important human capacity (yeah, it actually is) of making mistakes . Maybe the robot will perform the greatest of violin concerts without a single mistake, but if an artistic performance is defined as "a unique moment that it'll never repeat again" (even if the performers, musical piece and conditions are the same), then how a robot, which can't make mistakes (humans make mistakes, not machines) can make art? IT CAN'T.
Side note: academic musicians usually never read and play a given music sheet like a scanner would do at 100%, a fact which is remarkable with highly technical demanding works for piano concertos, such as the works of Liszt, Brahms or Rachmaninov. They usually play 80%-90% of all the notes... and do a lot of mistakes along the way.
What make us organic, human... living beings ? Making mistakes and learning from them. Something a machine will never do, if you remove the human factor.
Sorry for two long posts, it was something my soul felt the need to type down
Leveling +110 all skills and completing stuff here and there
06-Apr-2016 17:55:50
Lady Deluxe
said
:
An Ur said :
4 years on forums and never noticed there is this thing in the bottom right corner of the chat box you can extent the box with. Whatcha talking about?
At the bottom-right corner of the quick-reply box, there's a tiny arrow to drag the size of the box which makes it possible to see a full post in one view without scrolling.
Pretty neat - I was enlightened of its existence just this week too lol!
An Ur said :
4 years on forums and never noticed there is this thing in the bottom right corner of the chat box you can extent the box with. Whatcha talking about?
At the bottom-right corner of the quick-reply box, there's a tiny arrow to drag the size of the box which makes it possible to see a full post in one view without scrolling.
Pretty neat - I was enlightened of its existence just this week too lol!
@RS_Erehk
09-Apr-2016 22:18:17 - Last edited on 09-Apr-2016 22:20:09 by Erehk
Maybe its a new thing!
Do you use Linkify, blue haired man with a shade of blue in it?
Do you use Linkify, blue haired man with a shade of blue in it?
I don't know what to put here.
10-Apr-2016 00:03:49
Quick find code: 23-24-312-63626936 Back to Top