Forums

\^_^/ Anime Discussion \^_^/2 Thread is sticky

Quick find code: 23-24-240-61239843

Nonon-chan

Nonon-chan

Posts: 4,859 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
@Ouji
You make some valid points, but it doesn't change the fact that it's not a good anime when you compare it to what's out. A few good characters doesn't make an anime and a good plot contributes greatly to the quality of an anime. If you ask anyone who's watched a lot of anime, they would most likely agree with me. As I said, Naruto is a beginner anime and it's true that without it there would be much fewer anime enthusiasts, but for the reasons I've just given it's not something that would qualify as a good anime. A reasonable critic would call it average.
Also, you're being ignorant in saying that every ecchi, harem, ect. anime is bad. Before calling out others on being ignorant, perhaps you should think about whether you have such a right to do so.
@Fear Kubrick
Cool, I just started watching C3 and I also look forward to Fate/Zero Season 2. :)

16-Feb-2012 18:00:15 - Last edited on 16-Feb-2012 18:12:08 by Nonon-chan

Chimera Ant

Chimera Ant

Posts: 218 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Sigh,. here we go again...
"You make some valid points, but it doesn't change the fact that it's not a good anime when you compare it to what's out. "
If you compare every average series to the best series, that would make them seem bad. If you compare Naruto to everything that is out, it would be a good series considering there is much worse.
"A few good characters doesn't make an anime and a good plot contributes greatly to the quality of an anime. "
That is where you're mistaken. That would make episodic anime bad. Now Naruto isn't episodic but it just a series that shouldn't be judged for it's plot because it delivers great entertainment on several more areas.
If you want I can give more examples of well developed characters in Naruto, but those two just really stand out. Bit awkward to judge the series on just an example of mine...=/
" If you ask anyone who's watched a lot of anime, they would most likely agree with me."
Fallacy.
" but for the reasons I've just given it's not something that would qualify as a good anime"
For the reasons you've given it's not something you like, for the reason I' ve given it's not a bad series, but not the best either.
"Also, you're being ignorant in saying that every ecchi, harem, ect. anime is bad. Before calling out others on being ignorant, perhaps you should think about whether you have such a right to do so. "
Wait, aren't you, like, doing the same and criticize me for it? Son, I am disappoint.
Btw, I've seen quite a lot anime in case you consider me some random narutard.
--------
@ Zoon,
You mean [C] The power of *something......*? Good series but I didn't really like it after episode 8 because it tried to wrap things up quickly instead of the slowpace combined with character development it used to have....Of course, NoitaminA always offers a good watch (except, maybe Fractale =/)

16-Feb-2012 19:00:18 - Last edited on 16-Feb-2012 19:26:18 by Chimera Ant

Nonon-chan

Nonon-chan

Posts: 4,859 Adamant Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I don't have time to explain to you why there are several things wrong with what you just, but I will not stand for your accusation that I'm ignorant. I recognize Naruto as an average, not as "Oh, that anime sucks ass," which, may I remind you, is what you defined as ignorant. Unlike you, I think about what I'm saying so that I don't sound like a hypocrite. And ask anyone around here and they'll say that calling every anime with one a genre that you may not like bad is pretty damn ignorant.

16-Feb-2012 22:58:17

Quick find code: 23-24-240-61239843 Back to Top