Forums
New skill - Butchery
Quick find code: 185-186-918-62880567
![[#EN8EI1LP2]](https://forums.rs/img/avatars/default.png)
Okay, I've read to about page 15 and a lot of the same stuff was being said so I decided to skip the rest and post all of what I've thought, ideas people have already posted that would work, and just point out all the different controversies in this thread.
First off, fish losing their value. When a carcass is butched, say a lvl 40 carcass, it will heal slightly less than lobster, and have slight stat boosts, still not outdoing herblore. Therefore, not killing off fishing, as they still heal more, and not killing off herblore, as it gives better boosts.
Secondly, the carcass drop system. I say none of the current meat dropping monsters should be changed, as they already impact new players games (when I first started I survived only off woodcutting trees and cooking chicken/beef.) I think that certain monsters that need to be worked on so that they can be made cookable (e.g. steel dragons) should be worked into the skill. For instance, you kill a steel dragon and pick up the corpse. You use some tool (maybe a hammer or just your longsword) to crack the steel body and then carve the meat into something cookable.
Lastly, there should be designated areas to butcher meat (like anvils and furnaces for smithing) and a buildable room in your POH which isn't in the kitchen cause they're already kinda crowded
. And to everyone who's "noezz i dun want to haz gore on my wallz!!!1" It's runescape, the closest thing I've seen to blood is the runes.
That's my thoughts.
100% Support.
First off, fish losing their value. When a carcass is butched, say a lvl 40 carcass, it will heal slightly less than lobster, and have slight stat boosts, still not outdoing herblore. Therefore, not killing off fishing, as they still heal more, and not killing off herblore, as it gives better boosts.
Secondly, the carcass drop system. I say none of the current meat dropping monsters should be changed, as they already impact new players games (when I first started I survived only off woodcutting trees and cooking chicken/beef.) I think that certain monsters that need to be worked on so that they can be made cookable (e.g. steel dragons) should be worked into the skill. For instance, you kill a steel dragon and pick up the corpse. You use some tool (maybe a hammer or just your longsword) to crack the steel body and then carve the meat into something cookable.
Lastly, there should be designated areas to butcher meat (like anvils and furnaces for smithing) and a buildable room in your POH which isn't in the kitchen cause they're already kinda crowded
. And to everyone who's "noezz i dun want to haz gore on my wallz!!!1" It's runescape, the closest thing I've seen to blood is the runes.
That's my thoughts.
100% Support.
17-Jul-2010 06:14:23 - Last edited on 17-Jul-2010 06:14:51 by gerzikules69
Aeria: If you look at some of the dungeons and battle grounds around RuneScape, you will notice red splatters that look suspiciously like red blood cells and plasma
In response to the most recent rebuttle, wanting a new skill doesn't justify making one that could easily be released as content in an existing skill. Even though you want almost everything to drop meat, that doesn't make it diverse and complicated.
At most, a cutting animation will be made, one sprite will be created for each of the following: animals, fish and birds, and items will be created from the sprites with slightly different shading and properties. If Jagex can create dungeoneering in a few years, this won't even take 6 months. Yes, some new creatures/locations could be made, but new content like that could just as easily be released for herblore, theiving, summoning, or, really, any existing skill or a combonation of skills.
Here is proof that Jagex will consider making this a part of cooking: Barbarian fishing. Cutting the fish gives you cooking experience, and gives you fish offcuts and roe or caviar. This is a good possibility for your suggestion: having some creatures that are harvested solely for their meat, and others that can be butchered for some valuable material, such as poisonous pufferfish meat that can be used for extremely potent poison, and either bait for hunting/fishing or some food that just heals by a small amount.
In response to the most recent rebuttle, wanting a new skill doesn't justify making one that could easily be released as content in an existing skill. Even though you want almost everything to drop meat, that doesn't make it diverse and complicated.
At most, a cutting animation will be made, one sprite will be created for each of the following: animals, fish and birds, and items will be created from the sprites with slightly different shading and properties. If Jagex can create dungeoneering in a few years, this won't even take 6 months. Yes, some new creatures/locations could be made, but new content like that could just as easily be released for herblore, theiving, summoning, or, really, any existing skill or a combonation of skills.
Here is proof that Jagex will consider making this a part of cooking: Barbarian fishing. Cutting the fish gives you cooking experience, and gives you fish offcuts and roe or caviar. This is a good possibility for your suggestion: having some creatures that are harvested solely for their meat, and others that can be butchered for some valuable material, such as poisonous pufferfish meat that can be used for extremely potent poison, and either bait for hunting/fishing or some food that just heals by a small amount.
18-Jul-2010 17:22:37 - Last edited on 18-Jul-2010 20:52:20 by [#EN8EI1LP2]
Quick find code: 185-186-918-62880567 Back to Top