Forums

Protean planks- worthless? Thread is locked

Quick find code: 15-16-230-66284166

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,176 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Necrotising said :
Dilbert2001 said :
SlR said :
Yeah, I was surprised you could make things with them at the Fort, seemed over-powered.


The Fort probably was released in February this year and probably was designed way back in mid 2022 or over a year ago. Back then, the business strategy of RS3 was probably trying to make more money from MTX, but as we can see lately the business plan has seemingly changed and now and they are giving us free stuff that was used to be MTX items and reducing the usages of other stuff we got the most from TH like protean planks.


they have always put stuff on TH then rolled it out into game to make way for new TH stuff - for example, the elite skilling outfits, everything that goes into the oddments store


What new TH stuff for construction? Nothing! They have been making new construction content like Fort Forinthry, and now they are making new content less, if not simply not, buyable from TH.

Elite Skilling Outfits don't come from TH now and for a very long time in case if you still don't realize. They aren't TH content at all.

31-Jul-2023 17:36:48

Brave Alain
Aug Member 2004

Brave Alain

Posts: 1,360 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
The title of this thread should really be "Protean planks - can't make money with them any more" as this is what most people are complaining about.

They are not useless as they still give XP with little effort and good for AFK.

01-Aug-2023 16:27:46

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,176 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Brave Alain said :
The title of this thread should really be "Protean planks - can't make money with them any more" as this is what most people are complaining about.

They are not useless as they still give XP with little effort and good for AFK.


Not letting protean plank being a money making item is the key point of this update. It is really a tradeoff between making money and getting more xp.

Actually, since protean planks can give us 225% xp per bar now, those who choose this training method will save a lot of money from buying planks. A gp saved is a gp earned, so it can also be viewed as a money making method for people training construction in the POH.

01-Aug-2023 17:53:30

Deltaslug

Deltaslug

Posts: 32,671 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I understand the reason behind this change.
Yes. It does nerf the actual functionality of protean planks.
It probably ups the value for things like reg planks, flatpacks, and frames simce they aren't as easily made now.

They still have some value, like protean shakes, protein, and bars where you still get xp in an expensive artisan skill, even if it isn't a "best in slot" training method.

So no, not completely worthless.

01-Aug-2023 19:21:13

Myers1222
Feb Member 2006

Myers1222

Posts: 41 Bronze Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
my biggest issue is i was using protean planks with flatpack depackers while making mahogany tables, but i wasn't actually using the protean planks. i would keep them in my inventory with the plank box with 100 mahogany planks and inventory of mahogany planks. Doing this allowed me to make the limit of 60 flatpack items on a portable workbench, which was actually achievable when using the brooch of the gods, the contruction skillcape, and the dungeoneering scroll to save planks. I was saving planks often enough with all that to make 60 mahogany tables that used 6 planks per table with just the 125 mahogany planks per inventory (100 in the plank box, 25 in inventory, flatpack depacker, and stack of protean planks), and even if i didn't save enough to make 60 without having to make up the difference with the protean planks in the inventory, i was saving enough planks to make at least 45 or 50 of those flatpack items consistently. now i can only make 21 at the most doing the same thing, and even if i save planks, i still have to click on the workbench again to use the planks i saved to make more. on top of all that, the artificer's measure can no longer activate when using protean planks due to the changes. this was the best way for me to grind the skill pet efficiently. i still do not have the skill pet and have been severely hindered in my attempts to get it due to these changes. i was planning on using this strategy to get 120 contruction during this double xp live event, but now it's not possible to do anymore. i ended up working on 120 construction with just the protien planks, which is not nearly as much xp per hour as the method i have been using, and is also doesn't give me a chance to get the skill pet since i'm using protean items now rather than just having them in my inventory to make the flatpack item limit 60 but not actually using the protean planks. this is all around a terrible update and i hope it get's reversed so i can go back to farming the pet.

07-Aug-2023 06:09:01

Dilbert2001
Jun Member 2006

Dilbert2001

Posts: 30,176 Sapphire Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
In case if you don't realize, the update mentioned on this thread was from 4 months ago.

In the most recent game updates, Protean Planks have been giving more usages alongside other protean items and are far more worthy now as we can convert them to DXP Tokens to get truck loads of new and existing items:

"With this DXP we are introducing an additional element - DXP Tokens. These tokens are earned by earning DXP Spirits intermittently while skilling* or by using Proteans and Dummies. Alternatively, if you have any unwanted Proteans, you can convert up to 10000 of them daily to use them on something more valuable to you!"


https://secure.runescape.com/m=news/november-graphical-updates--dxp---this-week-in-runescape#

16-Nov-2023 18:15:55

Quick find code: 15-16-230-66284166 Back to Top