A couple things, to be clear:
I'd advocate a
gradual
change to any new rules in the clan. That is, at least for the first week or so, we definitely shouldn't kick for anything that we wouldn't have kicked for in the past. Some off topic is going to happen, especially when the market is quiet and there's no merchanting conversation going on. Trying to regulate that would probably be counterproductive. The only people who should probably eventually be removed from the clan are those who are openly hostile to newcomers and won't change that behavior.
I don't think attempting to censor manipulation will be useful. I know that rule is well intentioned, but enforcing it will be a nightmare because it's often impossible to distinguish earnest advice from manipulation. Further, because obvious manipulation is obvious, it's usually not even very dangerous!
All that said, I think done carefully this change will be a positive one that brings new life into the clan. Best of luck, Ploow, and many thanks to Zaka for the work he's put into this clan over the years!
05-Dec-2015 15:53:01