Even though I loved RS back in the day, just loved it and specially in the f2p days, it was sooo very social and I had sooo much fun. I haven't actually played oldschool RS, I think it's because I want to support and be apart of RS's game play today and ... Also what I hear oldschool isn't really oldschool how I'd remember it... So my answer is RS3...
My tea:coffe ratio is something like 10:1, so I suppose when I do have coffee I savour it far more.
Deadpool or Boba Fett?
Boop!
........................................................................................
Old School
...................................................................................