Forums

Echoes of the Gods

Quick find code: 49-50-885-60972658

Chuk

Chuk

Posts: 14,177 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
HOLY SMOKES! CHUK ADDED!
Who would've thought it possible, eh? But after eight long months, Chuk's got five new posts for y'all to peruse. Please, have a look. Half-way down page four. The rest of Chapter Two shouldn't be too far behind those.

12-Aug-2012 12:12:06

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
"and when he saw a rabbit by the path, it’s soft nose twitching,"
Reminds me of that bunny I buried yesterday.
Well, anyway, it's been awhile since I was last here. Your use of wording and description is still, say, not much other than excellent. I really like how you do have a focus on the minor things, such as mentioning a songbird and then a squirrel chattering back, so many nice things amidst the bad mood, yet there's something there to be a disappointment (for the protagonist). Very much like what happened to me that I talked about on the SD. Still, I do believe that authors must have a focus on smaller things, sometimes secondary or even tertiary elements, to tell a good story. You forget to capitalise some names, though.
My only complaint is that you made five posts in eight months. I guess now I have to punch my mom's cat in the face.
Personally, I find that I type most efficiently during late night. Just thought I'd mention that :P

13-Aug-2012 06:03:15 - Last edited on 13-Aug-2012 06:04:07 by Azigarath

Chuk

Chuk

Posts: 14,177 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Oh, I find the same hours to be my most productive as well. And actually most of this writing has been in the past month. I failed - almost entirely - to work on this at all for the first half of the year. I don't even know why, looking back. But I'm hoping to get back into writing much more regularly. I've got some more posts I plan to type up here in a couple hours, then I've gotta wrap up Chapter Two, and start Chapter Three. Hopefully I can keep going, at least as long as summer lasts and I don't have school to worry about.
Late writing also leads to those missed capitalizations and other typos. I just went through those five posts, and there sure are an awful lot of missed keys. XD
Thanks for reading. I hope you continue to enjoy it. :)

13-Aug-2012 06:47:35 - Last edited on 13-Aug-2012 08:10:21 by Chuk

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I just read the five posts! Well, unfortunately, I found the approaching bandits to be a somewhat common scenario to break emotion in stories. I have read similar happenings in other stories here and there, and very often the villains are smirking, sneering, grinning, and so on before getting owned, and I feel that's losing effectiveness.
Speaking of the bandits, I do recall that the description mentions that most of the trees were saplings, so it's a bit odd how the bandits could just sneak up like that, or was there something I missed? To be frank, whenever I was in the bush, I could hear others walking around more than twenty feet away, so I'm just a little fidgety about how a few guys could act as ninjas. Well, the focus for Ale was Ahr (pardon the abbreviations, the names are hard to type), so I suppose it's fair he just didn't see the fat guy coming.
It is realistic for bandits to be a bunch of cowards, though, a bit too clean the action was but that's just me; for example, when Ale had his foot on the guy's wrist, couldn't he just punch Ale in the groin with his free hand? It also seems to be a cliché when a villain swings horizontally at someone's head, the someone ducks, and defeats the villain; I've just seen that quite often basically everywhere.
Well, the bandits really were a bunch of sissies, and even in my own life, I have noticed that bullies are cowards, I just stepped up to them angrily and they reconsider what to do. I do get a few chuckles reflecting about those few moments in high school, but that doesn't matter.
Actually, it's not really worthwhile to complain about two posts, it's just the beginning of the story after all, but I didn't want to feel useless. The brief duel scene was a bit too passive at least from my point of view, and I have practised swordsmanship to a minuscule extent.

15-Aug-2012 07:56:27

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Anyways, here are a few good YT uploads that I would recommend watching fully, portraying true swordsmanship (which I'll never have) that I feel will be much better than anything I can type about:
(just fill-in what needs to be so of course)
http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=TtNZQBc4RpE&feature=related
(Note in the latter half of the video that the swordsman on the left was numerous opportunities to literally end the other guy's life with a simple thrust)
http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=Fv-Vut0xb9Y&feature=related
http://***.youtube.***/watch?v=1S_Q3C**Zmg&feature=relat
(Imagine the maneuvers being done with razor-sharp swords against people without armour)
If you already had knowledge about similar techniques then forgive my ignorance. :P I'd also suggest looking at film series titled Warriors, Weapons That Made Britain, and Conquest as these series depict actual combat with various weapons, but Conquest is sometimes unauthentic. They are also on YuTu, just type in Spartan Vengeance for a start about the series on Warriors.

15-Aug-2012 07:56:35 - Last edited on 15-Aug-2012 07:59:03 by Azigarath

Chuk

Chuk

Posts: 14,177 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Honestly, at this stage in the story, it's supposed to simply be a scene to show that, at least when the opponents haven't had years of training, Aletayr lives up to his hype of being the best swordsman. Can't say I really wanted to focus on the battle, which means maybe in a future revision, I would cut it entirely.
And I do admit, I know next to nothing about sword fighting of any sort. Only education is watching Lord of the Rings, and the lightsaber battles from Star Wars (yay choreography!) combined with my own imagination of what's possible.
When I was typing up the story from my notes, I realized that standing on the wrist that long was a bit of a weak spot, but I couldn't think of an immediate fix, and in the end it's not crucial to the story; I just let it be, so I could focus on getting where I really want to get to. I assume this sort of thing is why most published works go through 3-5 revisions before even seeing an editor. There are things you write when you're drafting and you put everything down on the paper that either need overhauled or removed altogether. In hindsight, I'd put this fight scene in that department, though probably as an overhaul, rather than removed, because of something that comes up farther down the line (which I can't spoil right now. :P ).
Anyhow, giving me all those sources should certainly come in handy for me. I need to do a lot of that sort of research before I try writing anything outside the RS Story Forums, I think. ^_^
As always, thanks for reading and commenting. It's definitely appreciated.

15-Aug-2012 09:07:03 - Last edited on 15-Aug-2012 09:09:00 by Chuk

Azigarath

Azigarath

Posts: 9,271 Rune Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Perfectly understandable, I just wanted to be helpful, I was beginning to have a hunch that maybe you were getting tired of my compliments. :P
Yeah, YuTu can be a powerful research tool, and there are so many good videos that it is essentially a big library of visual knowledge. Ancient Discoveries is also an excellent series that sometimes focus on medieval weapons, tactics and armour, but the Ancient world, from Rome to Greece, Egypt to Persia, and India to China, is all truly fascinating too. Many great fictional ideas can sprout from unusual historic fact after all.
Oh, and I would also suggest looking at Cold Steel's demonstrations for their products; they cut apart pig carcasses and such that gives a good idea of the power of blades.

15-Aug-2012 20:34:11 - Last edited on 15-Aug-2012 20:40:46 by Azigarath

Quick find code: 49-50-885-60972658 Back to Top