The purpose of an appeal is not to ask Jagex for forgiveness - its to ask Jagex to take a second look at a ban to determine if it was applied correctly. If that offense was committed on the account the appeal will be denied every time, because no mistake was made.
Given you have stated both in the opening post and in the most recent post that the ban was applied correctly and you did macro on the account, there is nothing that an appeal will resolve here.
This thread is now closed, as continuing to ask for second chances is not going to change the answers which you were given.
11-Nov-2023 18:26:36