Forums

Overall it looks great.

However I do have a few 'opinions'.

• MLM exp boost might be a bit too high. If the dairy has something like a 95 non-boostable requirement my point is moot.

* Noted DKS bones should be an elite reward.

• Mole locator is better placed in the hard rewards.

• How much is a small fee according to the Nardah herbalist? We get too little info here.

• Free noted pure ess seems like a useless reward.

• Why were we not given the stats on all the task set items except for the cloak? Should we just see them as cosmetics?

• Will the exp lamps from the karamja tasks be boosted to match the other tasks? Will be a bit weird otherwise.

That was all i think. Great first draft guys, looking forward to more information!

28-Nov-2014 23:36:17 - Last edited on 28-Nov-2014 23:38:53 by Papaya Pig

28-Nov-2014 23:47:14

XP lamps
- These seem fair enough although I don't really see any point in giving these out, they just seem like "XP just because you did something"

Ardounge
50% more fish & marks of grace seems very high, I know its an elite diary but 25% should be enough to make a difference.

Falador
- Prayer restore would be powerful, I dont know if rs3 has that but I dont like it.
- 10% more experience of the falador farm is very powerful, perhaps change this to yield 10% more crops.
-10% & 20% more experience from mining pay dirt is powerful, it's already the best XP with banking ore you can get. Perhaps change this so you can get paydirt faster or have a chance of getting more pay dirt in 1 swing

Fremenik
- Sounds perfect

*andarin
- Extra logs when cutting normal trees, this should be like a 10% chance, then as you complete the harder clues it moves to 50%.
- Coal trucks increasing your coal is good, but 240, 208 and 200 coal banked is very powerful. Perhaps make it so 250 is the max coal and you can pay an NPC a few GP to bank 200 coal a day.
- 10 % extra experience a day for maples is powerful, perhaps a 10% chance of getting two logs.
- Skipping a barbarian assault wave once per day. How would this happen. do you need a full team to do it? This doesn't sound very practical
- 50% discount from otto, this seems like a lot, perhaps a 25% discount would be better.

Karamja
- One fight cave resurrection per day. What exactly is this? does it mean you can die and get full health again.

Lumbridge & draynor
- In*eased Xp from tears of guthix. How much? I want to know if it would be too much or not. RIP Forums
Finally we have signatures in the surprise forum update. I'm Lewis, I play Old School & I've been playing since 2005.

28-Nov-2014 23:56:26

Mortania
- 50% more prayer experience from shade remains. This is a lot of XP bonus, I'd suggest making it faster.
- Double runes from barrows should be elite diary, and 25% should be hard
- 10% more xp at the slayer tower when on task. This is a lot of XP, perhaps you get an increased drop table from them
- 50% more firemaking experience from shade remains. I'd suggest making it faster instead of more bonus XP

Western provinces
- Ability to upgrade void top and bottom to have +3 prayer bonus should be elite, and +2 should be hard.
- I'm also unsure about how powerful the crystal halberd will be, I have a feeling it'll be similar to the granite clamp (Which shouldn't be in game because it didn't pass a poll).

Wilderness
- 50% more lava shards, this should start as 10% and increase up to 50% for the elite rewards
____
Generally I think less XP based rewards and more chances of getting items faster or getting multiple items at once. RIP Forums
Finally we have signatures in the surprise forum update. I'm Lewis, I play Old School & I've been playing since 2005.

28-Nov-2014 23:56:29

28-Nov-2014 23:59:53

29-Nov-2014 00:15:28