Original message details are unavailable.
I presume this was aimed at me because of my thread?
Not you alone, but yes your thread is part of it.
It was also aimed at those that wheel out 'Comp means completing everything' as if Trim doesn't exist.
This shows that the reqs came first - then the names were chosen.
So many people now go backwards and suggest the name of the capes should define the reqs.
The name shouldn't redefine the requirements - any new requirements should just be matched to the original intent of the cape.
As for the 'Ghast' example, you could also make the same point about Dom Tower - but when these 2 things were added to 'Diaries/Tasks' they did fit in with what the Task system was.
And because the Tasks were a Comp req, it then made sense that they moved from being required only for Trim to being need for Comp - because the original intent was that all Diary/Achievements were Comp reqs. They weren't moved - they became Comp reqs by association with Tasks.
These reqs weren't moved on their own, they were moved because they logically fell in line with the reqs as designed. If they were never added to Achievement Diaries - they would never have been changed from being Trim reqs only.
Using these as examples to modify the intent of Max Cape is a Red Herring.
21-Aug-2015 14:36:12
- Last edited on
21-Aug-2015 15:21:04
by
aSp