You have been replying to his posts since January 11th. Even quoting him and replying back.
I can't see a single post that breaks the Forum rules. So at this time I can't see any action that needs taking on said thread.
As for going to Review again I see no issues that can be reported there as No F-Mod actions were needed at this time on said thread. It would be a waste of Jagex time to goto Review.