@ Ownage Omg - As the thread is currently, it reads like a suggestion (or even a demand).
If you'd like to edit the first post to make it clearer that you just want to have a hypothetical discussion, and then request a title edit to removed the "We need" and replace it with something along the lines of "What if", then it could be appropriate to move back to the General Forum.
However, there still is no indication in the opening post that it is not a suggestion thread. It does not say anything along the lines of "this is just to gather thoughts and is not actually a suggestion", or "this is a hypothetical discussion, not an actual suggestion"