- This has already been answered direct to you, via email, by Mod Balance.
iRedEyes
- FMod action was correct.
Don Don Don
- which ever member of the CM team is assigned to the Moderation review thread examines the cases and discusses their rulings with the team. You cannot request a specific JMod review the matter for you.
Don Don Don, ReaperRising, Sparro
- These thread has been attempted to be re-created several times and each time met with the same response. The FMod actions have been and continue to be correct. Creating new threads to disagree with moderation actions is not appropriate and continuing to do so will be considered disruptive behaviour.
Further - it is not a single FMod locking the threads you have referenced and all the locks have been correctly placed, for the reasons provided by the FMods in question. Not every item needs a price check thread and the CM team are in agreement these do not. Please do not continue to start threads on this issue.
Yozora
and
Camini
- While we do think it is a really cool thing, it is advertising other games and will push people to links and websites we cannot assure the safety of - it falls under those rules. The FMod action was appropriate.
[#7IZQ2YOL8]
- It was not a constructive or useful addition to the conversation. FMod action was appropriate.
Melfice
- It was not feedback on the recent update, but rather a suggestion of additional creatures that should be worked on and was being solely bumped by the thread OP. FMod action was appropriate.
Dreamlette
- These were reserved posts placed immediately on posting about a dev blog and not an attempt to actually comment on the content. Given the need for open discussion about the content being proposed it seems inappropriate to allow reserves without comments which could then be altered and steer late arrivals to discussion. It is not a response we would want to encourage.
I have also referred to you by name as opposed to a suggested pseudonym - this is because it would rapidly become impossible for another JMod to track to discussion at a later date if I did. Please do not request the use of pseudonyms.
TheStory
- Please use the format requested in the OP to submit moderation actions for review.
5-x
- Thread unlocked.
24 JackBauer
- The FMod action was appropriate. Bugs of this nature should be reported using the appropriate mechanisms and not discussed on the forums as they are prone to exploitation otherwise.
iSahara
- I'd like to remind you that FMods are regular players and forum posters just like the rest of you and that being a Moderator is secondary. Everyone is going to have their own posting styles and decisions may vary from one mod to another. They will only moderate when they need to and their personal opinions should not cloud their judgement on their decisions. In this case while some elements of the post was sarcastic very real advice was give - if you are not happy with the posts a particular Mod is making I advise not reading them, we are not going to stop that FMod from being able to post.