forums.rs

Forums

~~~Guthix God Wars Dungeon~~~

Quick find code: 185-186-94-65197576

of 10
Aquamancer
May Member 2011

Aquamancer

Posts: 2,047 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Any-sao said :
Tsuneo said :
No support. I agree with Mr Cow, Guthix didn't want any followers so the idea that he has a general is a bit off. Plus when doing TWW he didn't strike me as the violent type.

Well, the same could be said about Zamorak and his followers. Zamorak claims he is not evil, just "chaotic". However, his followers are indeed evil.

Guthix is a peaceful God, that much can be said. But his followers, such as the Void Knights, are not necessarily peaceful. Who says that during the third age, a rag-tag group of Guthixians didn't try to form their own defence force?

Indeed. And since you apparently didn't read my thread, let me quote my own thread:

Aquamancer said :
Some of you might say that Guthix was the one who ended the God Wars as he woke up by the destruction of Forinthy, so why would've he created an army and joined to fighting, making him just as bad as the other gods? Or that since Guthix was against the idea of war, why there should be Guthix GWD chamber?

My answer: By the end of Third Age, Guthixians thought the God Wars had got out of hand, and they decided to end it and according to Unofficial RS Wiki, Guthixians participated to battle at God Wars Dungeon to prevent the conflict from escalating further. The Guthixians back then were a bit like the Godless today, but unlike the Godless who fight for a world with no gods, the Guthixians fought for balance. They didn't need Guthix with them to do this.

Also it probably wasn't Guthix who created the army, but a group of militant extremist druids who had grown tired of waiting for their god and so decided to take arms in the name of balance to put the end to the God Wars.
Really, the only reason for Guthix GWD not existing would be Guthix not allowing his followers to fight for him at the end of the God Wars, but even then there would be those who'd defy his orders.

10-Dec-2013 11:55:30

Zebub

Zebub

Posts: 18,298 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I like the idea, I made an idea about a Guthixian camp a year ago in one of my quests . I mostly focused giants as the main fighters of the Guthixian army, with a powerful steel, iron and bronze giant as boss.

I do think lore-wise Guthix could have formed an army. He isn't a pacifist after all. It would be unnecessary to alter existing lore.



~ There must be
Tranquillity
and
Conflict
,
Liberty
and
Control
,
Order
and
Chaos
,
Collectivity
and
Individuality
, there must be...
Balance
! Join the 9th faction: Guthix! ~
~ There must be Tranquillity and Conflict, Liberty and Control, Order and Chaos, Collectivity and Individuality, there must be... Balance! ~

29-Dec-2013 14:02:37 - Last edited on 29-Dec-2013 14:20:47 by Zebub

RuneScaqe3
Dec Member 2011

RuneScaqe3

Posts: 461 Silver Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
I do love guthix and wish that such thing had existed.
I think that the one issue would be that now the whole lore is made and guthix could not have been part of the gwd.

Only possibility may be something similar to the order of acsension that participated in part of the war, but was a bit late in action.
Yukiedosato
of the
Far East

You Tube:
Yukiedosato RS

I like sushi...

31-Dec-2013 13:19:06

Zebub

Zebub

Posts: 18,298 Opal Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
RuneScaqe3 said :
Only possibility may be something similar to the order of acsension that participated in part of the war, but was a bit late in action.
Ascension only exists since Fourth Age... That's even more lorebreaking.



~ There must be
Tranquillity
and
Conflict
,
Liberty
and
Control
,
Order
and
Chaos
,
Collectivity
and
Individuality
, there must be...
Balance
! Join the 9th faction: Guthix! ~
~ There must be Tranquillity and Conflict, Liberty and Control, Order and Chaos, Collectivity and Individuality, there must be... Balance! ~

11-Jan-2014 15:08:22

Aquamancer
May Member 2011

Aquamancer

Posts: 2,047 Mithril Posts by user Forum Profile RuneMetrics Profile
Zebub said :
RuneScaqe3 said :
I do love Guthix and wish that such thing had existed.
I think that the one issue would be that now the whole lore is made and Guthix could not have been part of the gwd.

Only possibility may be something similar to the order of ascension that participated in part of the war, but was a bit late in action.
Ascension only exists since Fourth Age... That's even more lorebreaking.

The thing is that Guthix was part of God Wars, although only momentarily right at the end of the God Wars, when he banished Saradomin, Zamorak and Bandos. Also, if we take Armies of Gielinor as canon, Guthixians fought the armies of other gods at the end of the God Wars. All this means that Guthixians and Guthix fought at the very end of the God Wars, and thus could have their own spot at GWD.

Zebub said :
I like the idea, I made an idea about a Guthixian camp a year ago in one of my quests . I mostly focused giants as the main fighters of the Guthixian army, with a powerful steel, iron and bronze giant as boss.

I do think lore-wise Guthix could have formed an army. He isn't a pacifist after all. It would be unnecessary to alter existing lore.
I remember that quest series of yours, although personally I don't think giants (asides the moss variant) follow Guthix. For my opinion, most of the giants are either non-aligned, Bandosians or side with a god/faction that is either really obscure or dead/dismantled.

Asuna sky said :
support! thanks
EntrTheLight said :
You got my support :D
Thanks for the supports, guys!

10-Feb-2014 07:55:34 - Last edited on 10-Feb-2014 07:55:50 by Aquamancer

Quick find code: 185-186-94-65197576 Back to Top