I have a problem with getting farming reputation, sometimes when collecting herbs there is a green rep drop but sometimes there is not. Anyone with the same problem?
I never really paid that close attention. Maybe the character is picking them too fast for the drop-down to keep up with.
In the very least, you should be able to verify your reputation before and after harvesting a plant. knowing the number of herbs you harvested and the reputation per herb, you should be able to calculate whether or not you're receiving the correct number of reputation points.