·¸·`·¸ Judging Rules ¸·´·¸·
1) Judging will take place immediately following the end of the competition. The judging period will end when an adequate number of people have rated others drawings.
2) Everyone who has participated in the art competition
are encouraged to
participate in the judging.
3) The host of the thread must
NOT
participate in the judging portion of the contest. The host will instead only post to break any ties that might occur during the judging portion.
4) When judging, you should rate based on the rating guide that follows
Rating guide:
Note: In your rating, do NOT rate based on colours
1: I have no clue what that is supposed to be
2: I think I can make something out
3: I don't hate it.
4: Not bad, could use some work.
5: It's alright
6: It's good.
7: This is really good.
8: I like it!
9: I love it!
10: I'm impressed, this is awesome.
6) Similarly, when rating give thought to the following criteria (courtesy of Nop Patar)
Things to think about when rating
¸.ˆ.*Detail
¸.ˆ.•Proportion
¸.ˆ.•Variety of Character Usage
¸.ˆ.•Resemblance of Intended Image
¸.ˆ.•Overall Flow and Transitions
5)
Do not give pity votes!
A pity vote is one that rates something higher than what it really should be just because someone feels sorry that they are getting consistently low scores. When you are judging it is important that you are
fair
.
7) Be
conservative
with your '10's. You should not be giving out 3 '10's in your rating. Use the rating guide to help with your decision if you are stuck.
8)
Do NOT rate based on colours.
9) I reserve the right to omit your ratings if I feel that you have given unfair ratings for other peoples artwork.
Note: I will only do this in extreme cases where it is flat out obvious, so do not worry if you are rating fairly.
21-Jun-2014 02:38:04
- Last edited on
21-Jun-2014 02:52:50
by
Cyanid
